Monday, June 23, 2008

The House Rules Cyclopedia (Part One)

This will be the first of my (weekly? Bi-weekly?) installments regarding the wonderful Rules Cyclopedia. Some entries will focus on House Rules, and others will revolve around some of the RC hacks I’ve used in the past.

Not including the Appendices and Contents/Credits sections, the Rules Cyclopedia contains around 263 pages. But, instead of wading through in order, I’m going to be using this Handy Custom Random Number Generator to generate a page number between 5 and 267. This will let me tackle the contents of the book rather haphazardly, and I embraced randomness long ago. Besides, I’m firmly convinced that a potential Hack or House Rule lurks on virtually every page of this book.

First result: Page 98. (Any readers should feel free to follow along at home)

Here, tucked away in Chapter 7: Encounters and Evasion we have a rather remarkable table (Subtable: 11. City Encounters). By combining the roll of a d8 with a d20, any of 160 people and professions are at your disposal to give that “Human” result from the previous tables a little more punch. Or one could use it to add a little more spice to the randomly encountered city denizen.

However, I have a feeling that this table is eminently more hack-able.

I'll be using this nifty online dice tool to help me take this table through the paces, and Yafnag is great for the occasional random name.

Subtable: 11. City Encounters (Page 98) Hacks:

Random Character Backstory:
These days, characters are rarely born in a vacuum, and some players just love fleshing out their character’s history and backstory for you. But this table can be used to give others a springboard, and the results can provide some excellent adventure seeds as well.

Example:
So, father was a Gambler (4.4) and your brother is a respectable Wheelwright (8.17). If father’s still alive, maybe he owes money to a (7.17) Tavernkeeper. Maybe your sister ran off with a (4.12) Guardsman. Childhood sweetheart: son of a (4.11) Graveyard Keeper. Best Friend: (7.5) Indentured Servant.

Even More Backstory?
What did your character do before becoming an adventurer?

Example:
Maybe you aspired to be a (8.10) Vigilante.
Interesting.
Who committed the crime? (4.5) A Gemcutter. Against who? (3.10) A Druid Adventurer.

Contacts
Continuing the theme of living, breathing characters, I’ve always been tempted to use this table to help tie players to a particular place by letting them begin the game with a few “friends.” Sometimes a character’s contacts can also be brimming with interesting story, hooks, and/or seeds.

I smell a House Rule:

HOUSE RULE:
Characters start the game with d4+Charaisma Bonus Contacts. Either randomly roll (my personal favorite) or choose some “contacts” from Subtable: 11. City Encounters. These “contacts” are people that your character knows and who are automatically considered “friendly” for the purposes of NPC Reactions. Remember that Armorsmith in the sample adventure from the Mentzer Basic Player’s Handbook who let your character trade his chain for plate? These NPCs are people have known your character long enough to do you the odd favor or two, and likewise if they needed help from you, you’d be hard pressed to refuse.

Example:
Artan the Fighter has 3 Contacts:
(1.16) Bazaar Merchant
(4.1) Freighter
(2.12) Carter
Need to stowaway somewhere? Looking for rare goods? Need help smuggling something through the city? There you go. Randomness sometimes produces results that go together like peas in a pod. This is one of those examples. Looks like Artan might have been a Caravan Guard or a Marine/Sailor at some point.

General Skills
Do you use General Skills? Need something for those pesky Profession (choose type) and Craft (choose type) skills?

Example:
How about Craft (4.8 – Glassblower) or Profession (8.20 – Woodcutter)? This table can really help characters fill in some blanks.

Retainers, Hirelings, Henchmen
Who doesn’t like Retainers (or Hirelings, or Henchmen)? Chapter 12: Strongholds and Dominions specifically refers to this table on page 138 in regards to retainers. The RC seems to have phased out the use of the term Hirelings (although the Retainers section does state that the two are interchangeable).

Example:
Hirelings weren’t always necessarily mercenaries for hire, why the extra sword-arm and treasure-porter you managed to hire might actually be a former (4.10) Government Official. Better yet, what if she still is?

Adventures
I’ve even used Subtable: 11 City Encounters in the past as a springboard for urban adventure.

Example:
First I use the table to make a few NPCs
(8.14) Winemaker
(5.1) Jailor
(6.11) Politician
(1.8) Astrologer

Then I embrace randomness, and try to string them together:
A superstitious Politician needs the adventurers help to get information from a local Winemaker about an alcoholic Jailor that he suspects of being susceptible to bribes. Along the way, the PCs will need to solicit the help of a greedy Astrologer.

Heck. Even a dungeon hook one-liner can work sometimes:
Go to the dungeon and rescue a prominent (5.14) Madame from the clutches of the goblins that waylaid her carriage as she was traveling between cities.

Urban Design/World Building
So you’ve mapped out that city/village/hamlet but what are all those buildings? How does this town relate to others economically?

Example:
Well, the small rectangular building belongs to a (8.4) Town Hall Employee, who also works as the town’s (7.14) Weaver. Another quick roll and (7.1 – School Teacher) tells us that that the building by the river is a School, while (4.19 - Hunter) can be interpreted to tell us that this town’s chief export might just be furs and skins. The (6.19) Taxidermist will tell you that most of the town’s imports consist of (3.4 – Diary Worker) dairy goods from another nearby village.

When coupled with a little bit of creativity, this table is positively brimming with ideas and has many more uses than just your standard “Encounter Table.”

Have you ever found a use for it in another interesting way?

Friday, June 20, 2008

My girlfriend is incredibly interesting.

So I was blathering on and on about how much I enjoy the combat mechanics of The Riddle Of Steel today as my girlfriend Candace was practicing on her ukulele when she provided a pretty nifty 4e House Rule.

See, she was thinking a little bit more about the 4e Combat System of Powers and their usage constraints. We played a really sloppy and quick combat session on Tuesday with the usual group and sure enough, Candace the RPG Combat HaterTM actually enjoyed what her Tiefling Wizard could do to control the battlefield.

Without further ado, I present a paraphrasing of her neat idea:

"I was thinking about the powers in 4e combat. You get your at-will, your encounter, and your daily powers, but what about a per-level power. An awesome, sort of David vs. Goliath thing for Clerics for instance."

Wow that sounds all kinds of cool. The economy of action in 4e virtually guarantees that players will be siphoning off their Encounter Powers toward the end of the battle, or their Dailies if an Extended Rest is eminent. But players only really have a rough idea of when they are actually going to level, so this might be something special that they want to hold on to "Just In Case."

I'm personally thinking about allowing this "Level" power to be chosen from the next level of Powers (daily, encounter, at-will, whatever is applicable to the situation). As a bonus it'll also help players get familiar with what they have to look forward to next level.

I've been blogging a bit 4e-centric lately, but don't worry, I haven't drank the flavor-aid just yet. I'll be returning to form very soon with a weekly "Rules Cyclopedia House Rules" column.

Monday, June 16, 2008

4e and Life Expectancy

Candace was casually thumbing through the Fourth Edition Players Handbook the other day at my request when she spotted something a little odd.

I needed her to give the book a glance because she's a set of relatively fresh eyes as far as Role Playing and Dungeons & Dragons are concerned. My reading of Fourth Edition materials tend to leave me either crumpled in a corner whimpering or foaming at the mouth and gnashing my teeth. Her perspective would have to be closest I could get to an unbiased view until I actually have a chance to play/run it.

She noticed that oddly, the life expectancies for virtually all of the pre-existing races had been reduced rather drastically. This wasn't too unusual really, as Fourth Edition seems to be more geared for "Heroic" play that centers on characters retiring at 30th level as challenging encounters dry up (granted, this could be rectified with future Paragon/Epic Tier Splats), so living to a ripe-old age is pretty out of the question.

However she did notice that Tieflings did not have a life-expectancy listed. This will probably be clarified and Errata'd into oblivion but it did get my gears turning after a fashion. Is it being tacitly implied that Tieflings are immortal barring hazard?

Odd.

Thursday, June 12, 2008

Back and Fourth

I wonder if anyone is contemplating an OD&D conversion of H1: Keep on the Shadowfell.

On the various blogs and boards that I frequent, there seems to be a remarkable lack of understanding between the grognards (self-styled or otherwise) and the unaffectionately dubbed 4ons (before this, it was 3etards, which also got a giggle from me). I think some of this friction could be due to the lack of a shared vernacular when it comes down to what each edition contributed to the style of play.

Ask a grognard about "shifting" or "feats" and the best you'll get is a blank stare.

Ask a fan of fourth edition about re-rolling hit points at every level, or the concept of "Race as Class" and you'll be met with the same reaction.

Many of the conversations are one-sided, with the OD&D gamers sounding suitably venerable and crotchety (with frenetic exclamations that often begin with "back in my day") while the newer 4th Edition gamers who have migrated from a crunchier 3.5 are busy drooling over potential synergistic exploits and cool factor.

For instance, after the "shift" to Third Edition, character optimization became character concept. I fail to see anything really wrong with that. My OD&D players optimized the heck out of their characters whenever they were given the chance, and as a DM (a mantle that when worn, does not give you the game-given right to be an ass) I encouraged this. The magical sword found in the crypt in Chandlerwood, the musty tome of forgotten fire magics found in an abandoned monastery near the Lavafalls, a set of Gnomish Thieves Tools that when commanded would be wielded by small spectral gnomes who actually climbed into the lock to pick it, the players loved these things because they made the characters more awesome. I know, "These goodies were handed out based on DM fiat" you protest! "Players had no where near the control that they have now!" Wrong. The only thing limiting player control is the DM, and as "bringer of fun" it's your job to insure this happens, not to tell your story. Seriously, your story is only mildly interesting at best.

But back to our sheep, what would be nice, however daunting, would be some transcripts of Actual Play for each of the editions, for the same adventure. This would do wonders to eliminate some of the fluffiness that causes the veterans to weep and the greenhorns to cheer. The crunch is what could serve as a universal language, the much-maligned "Common Tongue." Even though OD&D didn't have rules for governing some of the things that the newer editions do, gamers and game masters everywhere still have the same baseline of creativity. All D&D games edition-neutered can be just as fun and memorable as each other, but very few have attempted to accept the challenge of dissecting why. Less rules in OD&D served as a springboard for creativity and house rules, but people are house-ruling things in 4e right out of the box. Why is this? The reasons seem to revolve around either More Balance or More Fun. The problem is Balance can be an enchantment applied to a FunBane sword. Just as Fun spells counter Balance.

A first level Mentzer Dwarf could Cleave as a critical hit house-rule (on a natural 20 naturally) with the approval of a non-adversarial referee. Is this balance, or is this fun? It is highly likely that 4th Edition is no more fun or balanced.

I think we all forget that there is no wrong way to have fun, and that D&D has been about fun since its conception. It is not now, nor will it ever be, "more fun." Rules and mechanics simply don't do that. Instead, rules and mechanics are there to tell you "how" and "when" and "where" a predetermined amount of fun can take place. While certain groups and play-styles may lend themselves to certain editions, they do not limit.

My initial reactionary thoughts on my WoAdWriMo contribution for this month were as follows:

A Chaotic Evil Dragonman Wizard and his Neutral Evil half-devil henchmen are disenchanting magical items across the land and systematically destroying the economy, it is up to our intrepid band of Neutral Good gnomish PCs to stop him.

Instead, I might try to eviscerate as much fluff and IP from H1 (a dangerous task, all things considered, as the last thing I want is to cleave through a swarm of legal minions). As purely a thought exercise, I believe that that Fellshadow Fortress is just begging to be a rollicking OD&D romp.

Or better yet, design an adventure that can be run in any version of D&D, so that my dreams of uniting players from all editions under a common banner may someday be realized, or at the very least, help to bridge the chasm of incredulity that players on both sides of Edition Canyon seem to be camped on.

Perhaps even better, an OD&D adventure with 4e feel and vice versa. Hmm.

Tuesday, June 10, 2008

Taking the Initiative

Some notes on Initiative:

Index Cards have been wonderful for tracking initiative.

As a self-admitted Index Card junkie, I have literally thousands of them lying around at any given time. When I discovered that my venerable printer could print on them, I began to print cards with enemy statistics for ease of reference. Once initiative has been determined I can scrawl this on a card and stack them in order to keep track of the order.

Possible ways to improve:

Currently, I only ask for the player’s Armor Class and Initiative score to place them in the pile. Noting Hit Points on the card seems like it would result in too much redundant bookkeeping. Perceptions skills, ranges, and other tactical tidbits could be useful though.

For Monster cards, the borders or backs of the cards could be used to store random numbers. d20 along the top and bottom, maybe damage dice along the sides. If these factored in bonuses as well, that would be snazzy. Even just damage would eliminate some of the rolls and quick math, shaving seconds off of resolution.

Pre-rolling Initiative for enemies has also been great.

I must remember to group enemies together though. This heightens the pace and can be really evocative for conveying the “horde” or “swarm” mentality of minor opponents.

Rolling Initiative at the beginning of the Session works wonders for communicating a sense of anticipation for combat or a tactical encounter during the session, and also makes adjudicating Surprise that much more Surprising. Rolling Initiative for the next encounter at the end of an encounter is also handy.

An idea: with any type of sequential combat tracking system, instead of turning to the player on their turn and asking for an action, solicit this action by narrating a shift in focus. Describe the perceptions or actions directed against the player whose turn it is to indicate their turn.

Example: Krycon Narssisimar and a Lutzel the Low are toe-to-toe at the beginning of Krycon’s turn. Instead of asking Krycon what he wants to do, get in the habit of describing what Lutzel is trying to do to him, turning Krycon’s action into a reaction to the narrative.

Monday, April 21, 2008

MKhexgrid

Just a quick note about some lovely software I stumbled across while trawling the internet for Numbered Hex Maps:

MKhexgrid - a hex grid generator

The following spec.txt file seems to be working really well to generate a full page of decently sized, numbered hexes:


columns = 30
rows = 20
hex-side = 30
grid-grain = v
output = png
outfile = tut3.png
antialias = true
coord-bearing = 90
coord-distance = 18


Numbered hexes are the only way to map, and stocking all the hexes on Index Cards means that adventurers are never wont for adventures.

Monday, March 24, 2008

Rolling Dice (cont.)

In my previous post, I expounded upon the difficulties of dice. Seeking a solution, I acquired a variety of plastic containers to test the hack.

The cases that seemed to suit my needs best were made by a company called Craft Mates. They were less opaque than others, and the added benefit of a locking mechanism for the compartments means that I can shake the entire container vigorously without letting loose a hail of dice.

Interestingly, my favorite flavor of the Craft Mates I purchased contains 7 separate alcoves, each large enough for 3d6. Can you say "Instant NPC?" Using a standard Attribute Order (STR, DEX, INT, WIS, CON, CHR), I can generate the crucial stats for a generic NPC with a quickness hereto only rivaled by the tiny BASIC program I wrote in Middle School.

For most utilities though, the seven compartment can be filled as follows: d100, d20, d12, d10, d8, d6, d4. Even the unrully rolliness of the standard pyramidal d4 seems to be somewhat better when the dice are provided with a limited range of motion. I'm sure there have been studies to determine the amount of "shakes" required in order to maximize randomness (just as I recall reading somewhere that shuffling the standard deck of cards seven times seems optimal), but three quick (and thunderous!) shakes seem to produce a pretty broad spectrum.

Naturally, the players have yet to adopt this practice. There's a fair degree of superstition that goes into most of their die rolls and it seems that convenience can't overcome their predilection for the skin-to-skin contact of rolling dice the old-fashioned way.

Search

Root Ring!

Labels

random tables (324) d100 (321) tables (163) encounters (143) OSE Encounters (133) OSE (132) magic items (44) dungeons (25) magical items (21) equipment (20) monsters (20) wilderness (20) wilderness tier (19) character generation (17) dnd (17) magic (17) treasure (16) spells (15) clerics (14) rumors (14) NPCs (13) generators (13) gear (12) hexes (12) hex crawls (11) house rules (11) spell features (11) BECMI (9) ideas (9) names (9) resources (9) RC hacks and house rules (8) advancement (8) dressing (8) plants (8) settlements (8) stocking (8) characters (7) cities (7) curses (7) dnd hacks (7) events (7) magic users (7) adventure hooks (6) animals (6) clues (6) dolmenwood (6) dungeon stocking (6) treasures (6) weapons (6) what tables (6) why tables (6) backgrounds (5) classes (5) domain tier (5) fairy tales (5) potions (5) religion (5) set dressing (5) shrines (5) world building (5) yoon-suin (5) character sheets (4) current campaign (4) doors (4) dragons (4) fair folk (4) food (4) foreground growth (4) hirelings (4) hooks (4) jewelry (4) mountains (4) reviews (4) team tuesday (4) tools (4) villages (4) 4e (3) Elfs (3) PCs (3) TROIKA! (3) WHITEHACK (3) abilities (3) armor (3) cantrips (3) carousing (3) character classes (3) character death (3) clothing (3) decoration (3) dm (3) domain (3) downtime (3) dungeon dressing (3) fauna (3) foraging (3) fourth edition (3) fungi (3) goblin project (3) hex stocking (3) how tables (3) landmarks (3) locks (3) maps (3) mentzer (3) mushrooms (3) overland (3) procedures (3) puzzles (3) questions (3) quests (3) religions (3) rules cyclopedia (3) spellbooks (3) swords (3) tells (3) traits (3) transcripts (3) traps (3) vignettes (3) wave crawls (3) where tables (3) wizards (3) Cairn (2) Dwarfs (2) ability scores (2) abstract combat (2) adventure seeds (2) adventures (2) backstories (2) books (2) bows (2) buildings (2) castles (2) city crawls (2) community projects (2) consumables (2) d&d (2) death (2) deities (2) deity disfavor (2) drinks (2) experience (2) factions (2) fairy tale friday (2) fighters (2) flaws (2) flora (2) folklore (2) followers (2) forests (2) furniture (2) gods (2) gorgon trail (2) habits (2) harry clarke (2) hazard system (2) herbs (2) hex crawling (2) hex-describe (2) hobbies (2) identification (2) identifying (2) journeys (2) knacks (2) lairs (2) lore (2) magic systems (2) magic-users (2) magical research (2) meetings (2) miens (2) mishaps (2) money (2) mutations (2) ocean (2) omens (2) portals (2) projects (2) reaction rolls (2) reagents (2) retainers (2) rituals (2) rooms (2) sailing (2) saving throws (2) scrolls (2) sea (2) secret doors (2) shields (2) ships (2) single-use items (2) skills (2) smells (2) special abilities (2) spending (2) spoor (2) staffs (2) stocking tables (2) strongholds (2) superstitions (2) tex-crawl (2) thieves (2) toadstools (2) traces (2) tracks (2) wonders (2) words (2) 20 minute dungeons (1) 5e (1) DR (1) GLOG (1) KtA (1) NPC Party (1) OSR (1) Rival Adventuring Parties (1) VEINS (1) aasimar (1) absent players (1) accessories (1) activities (1) adventurers (1) alchemists (1) alcohol (1) alignment languages (1) altars (1) ammo (1) ammunition (1) angels (1) arduin (1) arrows (1) art (1) artifacts (1) axes (1) backpacks (1) bags (1) balms (1) bards (1) beans (1) belts (1) berries (1) birds (1) blessings (1) blogging (1) blogosphere (1) body art (1) bookshelves (1) boons (1) boots (1) bounties (1) bracelets (1) bracers (1) breath weapons (1) brooks (1) businesses (1) calendars (1) campaign starters (1) camping (1) candace (1) candles (1) cards (1) cartography (1) celestials (1) ceremonies (1) clergy (1) cloaks (1) clubs (1) coins (1) cold iron (1) collective nouns (1) combat (1) comic relief (1) commodities (1) common (1) commune (1) complications (1) connections (1) containers (1) corridors (1) cosmology (1) couplets (1) creeks (1) critters (1) crossbows (1) crowdsourcing (1) customs (1) d12 (1) d36 (1) d66 (1) dances (1) debts (1) deception (1) deeds (1) defenses (1) dilemmas (1) dimensions (1) discoveries (1) diseases (1) divination (1) divine (1) dogs (1) donkeys (1) downloads (1) drawbacks (1) encounter activities (1) encumbrance (1) energy drain (1) excuses (1) experimenting (1) exploration (1) fairies (1) fairy (1) familiars (1) features (1) festivals (1) fey (1) finances (1) fines (1) fish (1) fishing (1) flow charts (1) foibles (1) foodways (1) fountains (1) friendly monsters (1) fruits (1) future campaigns (1) galmours (1) game jams (1) gardens of ynn (1) garlic (1) garments (1) gary gygax (1) gauntlets (1) gems (1) geography (1) girdles (1) gloves (1) goblins (1) goo drinking (1) grimoires (1) groups (1) gullets (1) hacks (1) hallways (1) hats (1) hazards (1) healing (1) helmets (1) hex features (1) hex-crawling (1) hexagons (1) hiding (1) hints (1) history (1) holiday (1) holidays (1) horses (1) humanoids (1) hunting (1) illusions (1) in medias res (1) incense (1) ingredients (1) initiative (1) insects (1) itch.io (1) jellyfish (1) keep 'em poor (1) keys (1) lamp oil (1) lamps (1) landforms (1) languages (1) lanterns (1) laws (1) legends (1) light (1) limited-use items (1) lists (1) locations (1) lockpicks (1) maces (1) magic research (1) magic shop (1) magic words (1) magical effects (1) mapping (1) masks (1) meanwhiles (1) memes (1) mentors (1) mercenaries (1) merchants (1) miniatures (1) misfortunes (1) modern (1) monster motivations (1) motivations (1) mules (1) mysteries (1) nautical (1) new spells (1) nouns (1) obituaries (1) objects d'art (1) ocean crawls (1) oceans (1) ointments (1) overland exploration (1) overland travel (1) overloaded encounter die (1) pastimes (1) percepts (1) perchance (1) perdition (1) pets (1) pits (1) places (1) planes (1) player characters (1) poisons (1) pools (1) pouches (1) pranks (1) predicaments (1) priests (1) procedural flow charts (1) process (1) props (1) protection scrolls (1) provisions (1) purses (1) quarrels (1) raise dead (1) rations (1) reasons (1) referee aids (1) relics (1) reputation (1) restocking (1) rests (1) resurrection (1) rewards (1) rings (1) rivers (1) roads (1) robes (1) rolemaster (1) ropes (1) rules (1) ruminations (1) saints (1) salves (1) sashes (1) scenery (1) scheduling (1) sea faring (1) seafaring (1) seafood (1) secrets (1) senses (1) sentient swords (1) session starters (1) setting questions (1) settings (1) shoes (1) shopping (1) side effects (1) side-effects (1) site features (1) sites (1) so tables (1) software (1) soirées (1) song tables (1) songs (1) sounds (1) speak with animals (1) speak with dead (1) speak with plants (1) spears (1) special attacks (1) special results (1) specials (1) spell casting (1) spell substitutes (1) springs (1) statues (1) statutes (1) stomachs (1) stories (1) streams (1) streets (1) strict time keeping (1) subsystems (1) surprise (1) swanson abilities (1) swansong abilities (1) table talk (1) task resolution (1) tattoos (1) taverns (1) taxes (1) tea (1) telepathy (1) terrain (1) the middle road (1) thief (1) thieves cant (1) tieflings (1) timekeeping (1) tinkering (1) tomes (1) toys (1) tpk (1) trade goods (1) traders (1) travel (1) treasure maps (1) trees (1) trinkets (1) turn undead (1) urban crawls (1) value (1) venoms (1) vermin (1) voronoi (1) wands (1) waterskins (1) weather (1) whence tables (1) wilderness stocking (1) wildlife (1) word games (1) xp (1) ynn (1) zero hp (1)

Blog Archive