Friday, January 30, 2015

Spell Features: Analyze and Charm Person

See this post for explanations and more information.

Analyze

1. Avaricious Eyes
If you have this spell prepared, you can instantly enumerate large sets of the same or very similar items. Most commonly used with coins, you have but to glance at pile and you know the exact number of coins (of each varying type) in a pile of 10,000 coins or less (if it's more, you know this fact, but it will need to be split into smaller piles before you can count it). You can also carefully study a gem, piece of jewelry, an objet d'art/de vertu, or a piece of fancy furniture for 1d6 turns and ascertain it's precise value in gold pieces by expending the spell. Pick a two digit number (or roll d%) and write it prominently on your character sheet. If you ever end up “counting” or “appraising” a value that ends in these numbers, the numerological feedback loop leaves you unable to utilize this feature or prepare this spell for 1d6 days.

2. Spell Book Feature: Palimpsest of Common Command Words
Your spell book contains a list of Command Words (1d6), each word is rated with a percentage (d%), upon encountering a command word item, you may pick a word and cross it out. If you roll under the percent chance for this word, it is the command word of this item. You can expend this spell to switch the tens and ones place of your d% roll. Your diligent research into this area of dweomercraft in between adventures allows you to add a new word to the list each time you gain a level in experience.

3. Know Lineage
With a sample of blood (at least a vial's worth), you can expend this spell to learn all about the lineage/bloodlines of a target, going back a number of generations equal to your level. One of your parents is not actually related to you.

4. Dagger Feature: Haruspex
Any dagger in your hand becomes a relatively gruesome tool for effective, but bloody divination. By using it to dissect the entrails of a animal creature that has been killed in your presence while you have this spell prepared, you can consult the creature's viscera to foreshadow the future. This is a gory and ponderous process that takes 1d6 turns. Once the examination is complete, you will possess the ability to detect secret/concealed doors with the same base chances as an Elf (Autumnal Variety, 2 in 6) for the rest of the day. If you choose to share your findings with others, your rambling prophecy allows you to expend this spell immediately whenever you witness one of them taking damage. Damage is rolled twice and the lower result is used. Livestock and other animals are preternaturally nervous around you (-2 to reaction rolls) and generally disobedient and skittish in your presence.

5. Tea Leaves
You possess some rather interesting tea leaves (enough for 2d6 cups). Brewing a cup's worth takes 1 turn and boiling water. The process smells positively lovely, the tea is delicious, and drinking it even heals 1d6 + HLSS hit points (quite useful in a pinch). More intriguingly, if you add a single drop of a magic potion to the cup before drinking (the strength of the tea mitigates any potentially harmful effects, or at least that's what you Master told you), you can consult the leaves in the bottom of your cup and they will provide you with enough clues to discern the potion's purpose with certainty. You know where this tea grows (several dozen hexes of ocean away, most likely) in the event you need to harvest more by the light of a full moon.

6. Familiar Feature: The Eyes Have It If you possess a familiar, and have this spell prepared you can spend a turn concentrating in order to see through your familiar's eyes for up to 1d6 turns. This process is disorienting however, and requires a turn to recover from, during which you are nearly blind. Your familiar cannot see colors and this is sometimes frustrating.


Charm Person
1. A Loyal Henchmen
Recipient of a Charm Person that you cast and went awry. It's permanent now as long as you spend at least a few hours a day with your Henchmen (sharing a few meals and conversing/interacting). As long as you have this spell prepared, the Henchman has max Morale/Loyalty scores and get's a +2 to one Ability Score of your choice. You've grown quite fond of your Henchman over the years. The Henchman also knows your most terrible secret.

2. Spell Book Feature: Hamlin's Concerto
Folded gingerly between the leaves of your Spell Book is a dogeared page of sheet music. You suspect it is for casting a much more powerful ritual version of this spell in conjunction with a simple flute and tatterdemalion attire, but you'd be loathe to risk such puissant magics at your current novice level of expertise. Still, you can make out the basics: By playing this tune for 1d6 turns after a promise of silver, you can choose to have either rats or children be affected by the Charm Person spell for as long as you continue to play + 1d6 turns (you can communicate with them telepathically during this process to issue simple commands), and this spell affects multiple targets (at least an entire Village worth of rodents/children, if it becomes an issue d10,000 and d1,000 respectively). Save versus Spells after the first 10 minutes. Failure means you get to begin a new and exciting life as a member of the species rattus norvegicus. As a minor consolation, you are a carrier of 2d6 fleas itching to spread your bubonic plague and you can also cast Charm Fleas Or Felines twice daily.

3. Spell Book Feature: Etiquette Book – You can devote 1d6 turns to studying your spell book prior to interacting with a different social class to engender a positive shift (up one category) to reaction rolls. Works indiscriminately on anyone from common carpenters to cabbage-headed kings. Shift your weekly living expenses up a category though.

4. Perfume
You have 2d6 doses of a marvelous and magical musk. After applying a dose the recipient will smell pleasant (no matter what) for a year. If you have this spell prepared and have applied the perfume in the past week, your effective Charisma Score is 2 higher (max 18), or high enough to engender at least a +1 bonus. You can expend the spell at any time to cast Charm Person on a target that can smell you, and they save with a penalty equal to your Charisma Bonus. Also, for the purposes of Saving Throw intervals (Rules Cyclopedia, Page 144), this target is treated as having their Intelligence Score lowered by your level (minimum 3), as long as you are doused in a fresh dose when the interval arrives. You have only one of these Charms active at any given time. Should you run out of perfume, manufacture of more requires some pretty extensive reagents, and this is a constant source of study for you. Upon gaining a level, you may attempt an intelligence check. If you succeed, you may learn one of the 9 reagents necessary to make additional doses, at the cost of your automatic spell gain. If the check fails, well...

5. Language: Harpy/Dryad
You can speak the language of either Harpies, or Nymphs and Dryads (choose one). You are also immune to your choice's Charms while you have this spell prepared. While out cavorting on your adventures, you try not to think about one of the following, based on this choice:
I. Somewhere a Willow weeps in the woods, alone with a broken heart. Elsewhere a Brook blubbers between boulders, ever so patiently wearing down mountains. Both take no comfort in knowing that they aren't the only one forlornly longing for your return. As each season's snowy and icy-still torpor brings more maudlin memories, their tears begin to turn to bitter rage at the prospect of sharing you.


If the prospect of a love Triangle this perilous makes you idiomatically or ideologically 180°, there's always option II.

II. Ostracized in her aerie, a somewhat struthious Celaeno meticulously preens her plumage for you whilst singing the saddest of songs. She's tried in vain for months to get her strangely wingless clutch to fledge.
Venetian Harpy via Forest Rogers: Fantastic Beings. “You never call...”

6. Familiar Feature: Serpent
If you possess a familiar, while you have this spell prepared your familiar grants you another saving throw against Charm spells (it can't abide divided loyalties). Your tongue is forked, and your familiar may assume the shape of a crown, diadem, or other type of ornate headgear. If you choose, you may cast this spell, and whatever target you choose can be inveigled by your familiar to perform tasks that would normally be considered contrary to their alignment or habits (still no Seppuku sadly, but anything shy of this is fair game). Before excitement overtakes you though, any new spells you prepare are chosen for you by your familiar (randomized) for at least one week, plus the normal time period associated with Charm Person based on your Intelligence (lovely page 144 again). It has just Charmed you in a way, and has unfulfilled aspirations of Power with a capital “P”, a penchant for corrupting established institutions, and a very detailed long term plan (probably involving Dragons, or at least those lovely Lamias and that one megalomaniac Medusa it's friends with). By carefully guiding your spell selection, it believes it can start seeing these undoubtedly dangerous plans to fruition.


Yesssss. My diabolic plot requiresss casssstingsss of VENTRILOQUISSSSM and FLOATING DISSSSSSC!

Thursday, January 15, 2015

Ablative Armor, or How I Stopped Worrying about Verisimilitude and Learned To Love the Abstract Nature of D&D Combat.


I am looking for OSR rules that use armour to soak damage rather than make harder to hit - anyone have those?

This is a perennial and interesting question, so rather than clog up the comments, I'll put my thoughts here. It's not my intention to discourage pursuits along this line, and I've included a few different ideas. Hope this helps in some way.

The easiest way to turn armor into a more ablative system probably involves incorporating something like DR (Damage Resistance from the 3e era). Typically, one would assign some DR values to each traditional armor type, but probably still preserve the Shield's AC bonus (as most of the defense provided does still seem to fit as purely deflection).

Just in case, here's what DR is: Any damage inflicted by an opponent is simply reduced by the amount of DR that the armor has, possibly reducing it to 0. So you make a little table (these values are only examples, and are problematic for reasons outlined later).

Armor Type
DR
Leather Armor
3
Chainmail Armor
5
Platemail Armor
7
Helmet (?)
+1
Et cetera...

I still love the old “Shields Will Be Splintered Rule” for homing in on the Shield “Soaking” damage as part of player choice (here's how it works: If a Character would take damage, they instead can sacrifice their shield and take no damage, the Shield is rendered useless). You could do this with all armor if you wanted, and have it all without any fiddly subsystems, but then combat turns into strip poker as character armor just falls off with each hit :).

Traditional AC just becomes the base for the system your using (potentially modified by Dexterity, or Shield, depending on the rules system you're going with). “Hits” become more frequent (since there is a “lower” effective AC all around) and subtracting damage for every hit makes inflicted damage lessen. So a “to-Hit” roll that doesn't meet AC is a “Miss” while damage is reduced for each successful “hit” meaning that a particular hit was “Soaked” in this case.

A good question to ask at this stage (before we dive in any further) is: What is your reasoning for wanting this change? I know a lot of people are dissatisfied with the Abstract Nature of D&D combat, but it's useful to think about what the perceived problem you're trying to fix actually is.

The most common desire is to try and graft on more simulation and realism onto the existing abstract combat system, and on the surface, ablative armor rules seem to stress that a hit "connects" instead of “wearing armor makes the character harder to hit.” But it's important to re-contextualize the line of thinking here.

Remember, a “hit” doesn't necessarily mean “connecting blow.” All a “hit” really means in game terms is the opportunity to inflict hit point damage. And don't even get me started on the abstract nature of hit points :).

Given the longish duration of D&D combat rounds, a “to-Hit roll” is pretty difficult to justify as a single swing. It's probably more akin to a series of strikes, feints, parries, etc. All looking for that perfect opportunity to “deal damage.” The “to-Hit roll” just tells you if that “perfect opportunity” came up due to a combination of luck, skill, the environment, and so forth. It doesn't even have to come from the weapon, it could be a knee to the groin, a bash with a shield, anything that impairs the opponents ability to fight for another round (in the case of eliminating that final and crucial hit point). 

If the problem you are trying to address is the general perceived "whiffiness" of roll, miss, roll, miss, roll, miss, or if you need a subsystem that can synergize nicely with weapon breakage/armor upkeep rules, then ablative armor can still seem like the route to solve this. But again, it isn't necessarily the best route to go (it does add complexity for example, and has it's own issues that I try to outline below).

D&D's abstract combat really is a “feature” and not necessarily a “bug.” DM Narration can accomplish the same thing as DR with no additional systems:

Gragach the Clumsy is a Goblin, and rolls a 10, which is not enough to “hit” Haglef the Mantled, who is wearing Platemail. It's very easy to categorize this as a “miss” which is a convenient antonymn for the word “hit,” but not necessarily what happened here. The narration of combat can fix this.

So you narrate "The Goblin's spear point glances off Haglef's breastplate" (see it's technically not truly ablative protection here anyway, it's not "soaking damage" it is actually making the character "harder to hit" in the sense that no HP damage is inflicted, you could just as easily say “The Goblin's crude bronze spearhead just isn't hard enough to penetrate the solid Steel of Haglef's Breastplate” for a more ablative interpretation, but the end result is the same) instead of a series of variations on "The Goblin Misses. Next."

Here's another example (it's easier to apply to melee exchanges, as Ranged Weapons have a built in “You Missed.” excuse that doesn't strain most players' and DM's suspension of disbelief too much. Trebego the Yellow stabs an ensorcelled Haglef (still clad in Plate with a Dagger). He hits, and does 4 damage. Under the abstract system, we just narrate and figure out what happened “Trebego's blade squirms it's way between the plates that gird Haglef's shoulder, managing to pierce flesh and glancing off the bone.” There is nothing intrinsic about Haglef's armor that protects him from the possibility of this occurring. Trebego just got lucky, or really knows how to stick it to Fighters from his underhanded training.

Ablative Armor's intention is generally to create combat situations where there are a lot of “hits” but little “damage.” This is already built into the system as it stands (it doesn't matter how they don't deal damage really), if you just use a looser reading of the definition of a “hit.”

We still try though. We want a sword slashing a Chainmail Gambeson to not manage to penetrate the links (it's the whole point of that kind of armor after all!). So we keep coming back to Ablative Armor to solve this problem, but it in itself creates it's own subset of new problems.

If you decide to go with Ablative Armor, it might be a good idea to make any DR values somewhat variable, either through the application of randomness (assign DR a die value instead of a static number) or perhaps incorporate some simple rules for certain weapons being more/less effective against different armor types (A Piercing Pick is deadly against Chainmail, A hefty Maul is just more effective at battering someone in Plate Armor, than trying to slash at them etc). It might also help to think long and hard about hit location, because most armor types are mixtures of different things.

Variable DR like this is useful in the situation that the enemy is simply not able to inflict damage on a foe due to their attacks. For example: If you assign Plate Armor a DR of 7, and a Goblin has a Spear that only does 1d6, the possibility of that Goblin inflicting damage on the a character wearing Plate Armor is nonexistent, no matter how well the Goblin rolls. The side effect though is this adds another roll to each “successful hit” and more rolls to arbitrate combat tend to slow down play ever so slightly (which adds up with each successful “hit”).

You're also going to have to work through most existing monsters in most systems and assign them an arbitrary DR value and a new AC as well. Is their AC high because they're quick and difficult to strike or extremely skilled or lucky? Or is their AC high because they can be hit easily, but are harder to damage? It's a lot of work, but some find this kind of tinkering fun :).

The final issue is one of de-protagonization, that is: it just isn't always fun for Players. No one likes to see their critical hit and high damage roll (“I hit him! Finally!”) reduced to 0 just because the monster has high DR. It makes an otherwise wonderful roll meaningless, and snatches this sense of victory out of the player's head and hands far too often. It chips away a the FUN. Combat becomes a “mother-may-I” situation, and in some cases combat drags on because Players just can't beat the high DR, either due to bad Damage Rolls or insufficient weapons.

Hope this helps a little bit with your quest. I wrangled with this “problem” for ages, but no solution I found or homebrewed really addressed the issue without adding more rolls and complexity. I think re-enforcing the abstract nature of combat (ie: it's not trying to be “real,” there are no “hits” and “misses” in the normal sense, just times when damage is dealt, and times when it is not) and achieving the desired sense of verisimilitude through narration eventually got me to stop worrying and learn to love it as is :). Doesn't mean I'll ever stop tinkering though :).


Wednesday, January 14, 2015

Rules Cyclopedia Hacks & House Rules: Page 109, Character Saving Throws

Rules Cyclopedia Hacks & House Rules: Page 109, Character Saving Throws
I've been toying with coupling each Saving Throw to an Ability Score, either to incorporate the Ability Score modifier as a bonus/penalty to each Save, or as shorthand for replacing Saving Throws entirely with a Standard Ability check (Ă  la 5e in a roundabout fashion). On this dog-geared page we also have the advancement tables, an infrequent but still rebarbatively necessary reference. Table Look ups like these are a favored enemy of mine.

Conventionally in BECMI, only Wisdom Modifiers influence Saving Throws in BECMI, and even then, only sometimes with Spells.

Here's my tinkering take:

Ability
Saving Throw
Rationale
Strength
Paralysis/Petrification
Gritting of teeth and thrashing as chalky gray stone creeps up your ankles or against the numbness of clammy Ghoul-touch. This is physical willpower.
Dexterity
Wands/Rays
Nothing surprising here. Simple dodging really
Constitution
Poison/Disease
Also pretty paradigmatic, health and haleness and the Immune system
Intelligence
Spells/Control
Interpreted in this case as one's mastery over their perceived “reality,” familiarity with the nature of magical effects, with a smidgen of mental willpower
Wisdom
Dragon Breath/Area Attack
Intuitively knowing that standing specifically there is a bad idea, and unconsciously avoiding to do so.
Charisma
Death Ray/Level Drain
One's sense of self, force of personality, and accumulated experiences

I like to embrace the disassociated nature of Saving Throws and how the results end up informing the game fiction. You'll notice that naturally, since the standard Saves amount to five and Scores are six, I've had to add one. I'm a sucker for symmetry. I decided to split Poison/Death to give Charisma some more oomph, since Retainer Loyalty and Reaction Rolls don't always seem to carry the impact they deserve with players.

I've also placed Saving Throws versus Spells under the purview of Intelligence, for as a Prime Requisite for Magic-Users, I think it's more useful there to support Spell Dueling and niche protection for the Class as the go to troubleshooters of all things Magical.

While I can recite the Class Saving Throws for first level by heart (along with THAC0 catechisms up to Name, oh the useless knowledge one retains), the tables all follow mathematically frustrating different progressions, necessitating a leveling libram-lookup that I'd like to eliminate on principal.

The methods I'm meddling with don't quite work as nicely as I'd like, because they seem to have the potential to decouple the Saving Throw progression from character advancement, but I must admit that a part of me likes the idea of the types of challenges that trigger a Saving Throw having a consistent degree of danger.

I smell some options.

The Perceived “Problem:” A table look up requirement is present to adjust Saving Throws when Character Leveling takes place. Ability Checks serving as understudies for Saving Throws seems to solve this on the surface, but then improvement becomes handcuffed to Ability Score inflation instead of character advancement. No thank you. What else can it be bound to instead?

Option One:
Perhaps allowing the player to pick one category to improve each level would solve this. I like the granularity of this degree of advancement and the emphasis on Player Decision, as it can telegraph to the DM what the Player is “frightened of.” Scrumptious.

The Player's overall odds of success on a given save will likely suffer unless there's some standardization at the starting line for the progression. Maybe establishing all initial saves at 15 to flatten the field a bit would work. This would introduce a little more survivability at lower levels, without diluting the gravity of Saving Throws too much in the long run. This starts unyoking Saving Throws from Classes though, which can damage niches quite a bit.

Example One:
Haglef the Mantled is a Fighter at level one. Before Ability Score Modifiers are applied, all Saves are set to 15. His Ability Scores are as follows (I'm using BECMI Bonus progression, naturally):

Ability Scores
Saving Throw
Need/Exceed
STR
16
+2
Paralysis/Petrification
13
DEX
10
-
Wands/Rays
15
CON
18
+3
Poison/Disease
12
INT
11
-
Spells/Control
15
WIS
4
-2
Dragon Breath/Area Attack
17
CHA
17
+2
Death Ray/Level Drain
13

What a guy! After Modifiers, his initial chances are in the above table.

At Level 2, the Player thinks back to a nasty Fireball trap that singed him severely, and he wisely starts shoring up his abiogenetic deficiency in Saving Throws versus Dragon Breath/Area Attack. With this option, the decision of which Saving Throw to improve can either be informed by Play, or out of desire to optimize and increase a character's odds of survivability. With 36th levels of improvement and draconically even dispersion, the final base saves for all categories would be 9 before Ability Score modification. Still not overwhelmingly outstanding odds, but Player Survivability remains a matter of personal preference. This keeps things scary.

Option Two:
As above, but if we were to increase improvement selections to two (either applied holistically to a single save or split) this has the interesting aside of setting evenly distributed Base Saves to 3 at level 36, which is closer to the 2 specified in the tables for the non-Demihuman Classes.

Option Three:
To address the damage to Class niche, we could always try grafting on some Class Based cruft onto Option One and see if it takes. The easy way: each Class also improves a certain Save when a Level is gained. To keep it simple, start with their Prime Requisite save and work your way down the listed Ability Score order before repeating .

The standard Saving Throw progressions already seem to enforce a degree of niche protection: Favored by the Gods, a Cleric is more likely to withstand the searing blast of Dragonfire, the lithe Thief deftly dodges the Transmogrifying Ray, the Magic User crushes the hurled eldritch orb to dust in his hands, etc.

Since the Prime Requisite Ability Score under this new alignment is somewhat tied to a Class' Saving Throw Competency, it could help enforce this aptitude in Characters with Above Average Primes, even if we eliminate the fiddly progressions and stick with 15 as a base save.

Example: Here are Haglef the Mantled's saves (after applying his somewhat striking Ability Score Modifiers) at each level, up to Name, with changes emphasized. Class based Changes are in bold red while Player Choices are in bold blue.

Saving Throw
1
2
3
4
5
6
7
8
9
Paralysis/Petrification
13
12
12
12
12
12
12
11
11
Wands/Rays
15
15
14
14
14
13
13
13
13
Poison/Disease
12
12
12
11
11
11
11
10
10
Spells/Control
15
15
15
14
13
13
12
12
12
Dragon Breath/Area Attack
17
16
15
15
14
13
13
13
13
Death Ray/Level Drain
13
13
13
13
13
13
12
12
12

Here Haglef uses his level-based choices to shore up deficiencies (whether perceived or encountered through play is unimportant), while a steady level-and-class based improvement takes place alongside these decisions.

Another Example: Trebego the Yellow is a Thief, and sadly he was born under a significantly less fortunate sign than Haglef. Here are his Ability Scores, Modifiers, and initial saves, followed by an example progression table. At least he's blessed with the speedy Level Advancement of the Thief Class.

Ability Scores
Saving Throws
Need/Exceed
STR
7
+1
Paralysis/Petrification
16
DEX
12
-
Wands/Rays
15
CON
13
+1
Poison/Disease
14
INT
7
-1
Spells/Control
16
WIS
7
-1
Dragon Breath/Area Attack
16
CHA
9
-
Death Ray/Level Drain
15

Saving Throw
1
2
3
4
5
6
7
8
9
Paralysis/Petrification
16
16
15
15
15
15
14
13
13
Wands/Rays
15
14
14
14
14
14
14
13
13
Poison/Disease
14
13
12
12
12
12
12
12
11
Spells/Control
16
16
16
15
14
14
14
14
13
Dragon Breath/Area Attack
16
16
16
15
14
14
13
13
13
Death Ray/Level Drain
15
15
15
15
15
13*
13
13
13

*A nasty encounter with some Wights at Level 5 convinces Trebego to “double-dip” during Level 6 advancement. I don't really foresee this being a big issue though, because the choice is always a trade off.

Tertiary Example: Let's look at a Player who chooses to optimize heavily on a single save: Euphranor the Mysterious, a Magic-User with the admirable goal of supreme mastery over the arcane arts.

Ability Scores
Saving Throws
Need/Exceed
STR
9
-
Paralysis/Petrification
15
DEX
16
+2
Wands/Rays
13
CON
14
+1
Poison/Disease
14
INT
14
+1
Spells/Control
14
WIS
11
-
Dragon Breath/Area Attack
15
CHA
16
+2
Death Ray/Level Drain
13


Saving Throw
1
2
3
4
5
6
7
8
9
Paralysis/Petrification
15
15
15
15
14
14
14
14
14
Wands/Rays
13
13
13
13
13
12
12
12
12
Poison/Disease
14
14
14
14
14
14
13
13
13
Spells/Control
14
12*
11
10
9
8
7
5*
4
Dragon Breath/Area Attack
15
15
14
14
14
14
14
14
13
Death Ray/Level Drain
13
13
13
12
12
12
12
12
12

* With a double-dip right out of the gate, it's obvious that Euphranor fancies herself the finest spell duelist in the land, and she also chooses to double down at level 8. By the time she's Name Level (Necromanceress, Necromantrix? Reminds me of a future post on Level Titles, I do miss those) she's a staggering force to be reckoned with by enemy Spell Casters. But this is not without cost, as her intense focus on improving this resistance has semi-stunted her other Saves, only her Ability Score bonuses keep her somewhat competitively arrayed.

NB: With transcendent Ability Scores and consistent choices like this, a Player could theoretically take the Save tied to their Prime Requisite down to the minimum of 2 by Name Level. I don't find this too alarming, but some might. Here a Player has decided, at the cost of other attractive choices, to virtually neutralize a single type of commonly encountered threat. Good for them. This is character customization.

With Ability Score inflation virtually nonexistent in BECMI, I see this as a way to surmount some of the challenges of an unimpressive 3d6 in order that typically grow old over time. I liken it to the choice of Armor type and Weapon outlay in a way.
I do see typical Play as an active, informing force and powerful prophylaxis for stymieing such a strategy, however, and I think it has a strong likelihood of exacerbating the difficulties associated with this degree of focus.
Euphranor would regale you with hows and whys, if she wasn't so laconically lichened and lithic, languishing agape among the grazing Gorgons that guard Bargle's gatehouse.

Improvement is still subject to the slower “ladling” with this method when compared to the interval based competency injection of the standard progression, but it does eliminate the frightful table look up: A Class' Saving Throw Improvement progression is right there on the Character Sheet, in the order in which Ability Scores are placed, always starting with the Class' Prime. Leveling introduces a difficult Player Choice with potentially long reaching consequences, which is always nice.

Option Three:
Start applying the Class bonus at Level One. I think this might match the math for the level 36th hypotheticals listed above a bit better, but I don't want to rework the example tables just yet.

Option Four:
This is where we inevitably start to stray from Hacks & House Rulings and into System Revision. Let's let failed or successful saves dictate routes for improvement (use it or lose it, similar to the BRP Skill Improvement methodology). No look ups required, just mark all save attempts.

Example: Good ol' Trebego the Yellow (Thief, first level) is thinking of changing his sobriquet to “the Unlucky” as his first foray into the Ruins of Acorn Manor is less than encouraging. While probing a tiny alcove with a gloveless hand, his finger is bitten soundly by a Tremor Rat, necessitating a save versus Disease, which he fails, contracting a bad case of the Twitch. But his cautious nature was still bacon-saving when dealing with the Giant Reticulated Puffball fungi that flourishes in the Wine Cellar. He made his Save versus the Spores (Area Attack), while his Party decided rather unsportingly to end their adventuring career right then and there in order to audition for new, if frightfully dull, vocations as fungal fertilizer.

Thankfully, fencing the family silver that he filched from the pantry grants him enough filthy lucre to petition a local Lama for a Cure Disease spell (and it's enough to gain a level!) Christened a Cutpurse (Level 2) by the local Guild, he can now improve two saves: Poison/Disease and Dragon Breath/Area Attack.

Here, we still only allow up to two improvements per level, but it's almost tempting to not limit the number of improvements at all. In this case, I would probably single out only failures to drive improvement, not successes.

This could have the side effect of moving Player Decisions, and therefore Character Action toward more risky and proactive danger-seeking directions. With Trebego's Player deciding to intentionally seek out a Poisonsmith to try building up an immunity to Black Dougal's Bane the “hard way,” everyone wins, or at least, everyone get's the opportunity to roll up new characters with frequency.

Option Five:
We could even try decouple Saves from Leveling entirely, and Improve Saves as failures or successes occur during Play. The choice of which is dependent on taste. It has always been my personal preference to hand out consolation prizes on failures, and let survival be it's own reward.

This seems a bit terrifying and terribly unpredictable though, as the frequency of triggers for Saving Throws varies wildly based on play style, and without save difficulty being moderated and bound to threats encountered (something that's done consistently in systems like 3rd Edition), it seems that the threat of Save situations is much more likely to lose it's delicious menace much more quickly than what would be categorized as “normal” for Classic and other Old School iterations. It is a variation that seems eminently compatible with heroic one-shots or shorter campaigns though.


Is a single group of tables really onerous enough to merit this much meandering? I think so, but obviously the options presented here won't be to everyone's taste. Hopefully there's a ore-bearing idea or two in this seam somewhere for someone.

Search

Root Ring!

Labels

random tables (324) d100 (321) tables (163) encounters (143) OSE Encounters (133) OSE (132) magic items (44) dungeons (25) magical items (21) equipment (20) monsters (20) wilderness (20) wilderness tier (19) character generation (17) dnd (17) magic (17) treasure (16) spells (15) clerics (14) rumors (14) NPCs (13) generators (13) gear (12) hexes (12) hex crawls (11) house rules (11) spell features (11) BECMI (9) ideas (9) names (9) resources (9) RC hacks and house rules (8) advancement (8) dressing (8) plants (8) settlements (8) stocking (8) characters (7) cities (7) curses (7) dnd hacks (7) events (7) magic users (7) adventure hooks (6) animals (6) clues (6) dolmenwood (6) dungeon stocking (6) treasures (6) weapons (6) what tables (6) why tables (6) backgrounds (5) classes (5) domain tier (5) fairy tales (5) potions (5) religion (5) set dressing (5) shrines (5) world building (5) yoon-suin (5) character sheets (4) current campaign (4) doors (4) dragons (4) fair folk (4) food (4) foreground growth (4) hirelings (4) hooks (4) jewelry (4) mountains (4) reviews (4) team tuesday (4) tools (4) villages (4) 4e (3) Elfs (3) PCs (3) TROIKA! (3) WHITEHACK (3) abilities (3) armor (3) cantrips (3) carousing (3) character classes (3) character death (3) clothing (3) decoration (3) dm (3) domain (3) downtime (3) dungeon dressing (3) fauna (3) foraging (3) fourth edition (3) fungi (3) goblin project (3) hex stocking (3) how tables (3) landmarks (3) locks (3) maps (3) mentzer (3) mushrooms (3) overland (3) procedures (3) puzzles (3) questions (3) quests (3) religions (3) rules cyclopedia (3) spellbooks (3) swords (3) tells (3) traits (3) transcripts (3) traps (3) vignettes (3) wave crawls (3) where tables (3) wizards (3) Cairn (2) Dwarfs (2) ability scores (2) abstract combat (2) adventure seeds (2) adventures (2) backstories (2) books (2) bows (2) buildings (2) castles (2) city crawls (2) community projects (2) consumables (2) d&d (2) death (2) deities (2) deity disfavor (2) drinks (2) experience (2) factions (2) fairy tale friday (2) fighters (2) flaws (2) flora (2) folklore (2) followers (2) forests (2) furniture (2) gods (2) gorgon trail (2) habits (2) harry clarke (2) hazard system (2) herbs (2) hex crawling (2) hex-describe (2) hobbies (2) identification (2) identifying (2) journeys (2) knacks (2) lairs (2) lore (2) magic systems (2) magic-users (2) magical research (2) meetings (2) miens (2) mishaps (2) money (2) mutations (2) ocean (2) omens (2) portals (2) projects (2) reaction rolls (2) reagents (2) retainers (2) rituals (2) rooms (2) sailing (2) saving throws (2) scrolls (2) sea (2) secret doors (2) shields (2) ships (2) single-use items (2) skills (2) smells (2) special abilities (2) spending (2) spoor (2) staffs (2) stocking tables (2) strongholds (2) superstitions (2) tex-crawl (2) thieves (2) toadstools (2) traces (2) tracks (2) wonders (2) words (2) 20 minute dungeons (1) 5e (1) DR (1) GLOG (1) KtA (1) NPC Party (1) OSR (1) Rival Adventuring Parties (1) VEINS (1) aasimar (1) absent players (1) accessories (1) activities (1) adventurers (1) alchemists (1) alcohol (1) alignment languages (1) altars (1) ammo (1) ammunition (1) angels (1) arduin (1) arrows (1) art (1) artifacts (1) axes (1) backpacks (1) bags (1) balms (1) bards (1) beans (1) belts (1) berries (1) birds (1) blessings (1) blogging (1) blogosphere (1) body art (1) bookshelves (1) boons (1) boots (1) bounties (1) bracelets (1) bracers (1) breath weapons (1) brooks (1) businesses (1) calendars (1) campaign starters (1) camping (1) candace (1) candles (1) cards (1) cartography (1) celestials (1) ceremonies (1) clergy (1) cloaks (1) clubs (1) coins (1) cold iron (1) collective nouns (1) combat (1) comic relief (1) commodities (1) common (1) commune (1) complications (1) connections (1) containers (1) corridors (1) cosmology (1) couplets (1) creeks (1) critters (1) crossbows (1) crowdsourcing (1) customs (1) d12 (1) d36 (1) d66 (1) dances (1) debts (1) deception (1) deeds (1) defenses (1) dilemmas (1) dimensions (1) discoveries (1) diseases (1) divination (1) divine (1) dogs (1) donkeys (1) downloads (1) drawbacks (1) encounter activities (1) encumbrance (1) energy drain (1) excuses (1) experimenting (1) exploration (1) fairies (1) fairy (1) familiars (1) features (1) festivals (1) fey (1) finances (1) fines (1) fish (1) fishing (1) flow charts (1) foibles (1) foodways (1) fountains (1) friendly monsters (1) fruits (1) future campaigns (1) galmours (1) game jams (1) gardens of ynn (1) garlic (1) garments (1) gary gygax (1) gauntlets (1) gems (1) geography (1) girdles (1) gloves (1) goblins (1) goo drinking (1) grimoires (1) groups (1) gullets (1) hacks (1) hallways (1) hats (1) hazards (1) healing (1) helmets (1) hex features (1) hex-crawling (1) hexagons (1) hiding (1) hints (1) history (1) holiday (1) holidays (1) horses (1) humanoids (1) hunting (1) illusions (1) in medias res (1) incense (1) ingredients (1) initiative (1) insects (1) itch.io (1) jellyfish (1) keep 'em poor (1) keys (1) lamp oil (1) lamps (1) landforms (1) languages (1) lanterns (1) laws (1) legends (1) light (1) limited-use items (1) lists (1) locations (1) lockpicks (1) maces (1) magic research (1) magic shop (1) magic words (1) magical effects (1) mapping (1) masks (1) meanwhiles (1) memes (1) mentors (1) mercenaries (1) merchants (1) miniatures (1) misfortunes (1) modern (1) monster motivations (1) motivations (1) mules (1) mysteries (1) nautical (1) new spells (1) nouns (1) obituaries (1) objects d'art (1) ocean crawls (1) oceans (1) ointments (1) overland exploration (1) overland travel (1) overloaded encounter die (1) pastimes (1) percepts (1) perchance (1) perdition (1) pets (1) pits (1) places (1) planes (1) player characters (1) poisons (1) pools (1) pouches (1) pranks (1) predicaments (1) priests (1) procedural flow charts (1) process (1) props (1) protection scrolls (1) provisions (1) purses (1) quarrels (1) raise dead (1) rations (1) reasons (1) referee aids (1) relics (1) reputation (1) restocking (1) rests (1) resurrection (1) rewards (1) rings (1) rivers (1) roads (1) robes (1) rolemaster (1) ropes (1) rules (1) ruminations (1) saints (1) salves (1) sashes (1) scenery (1) scheduling (1) sea faring (1) seafaring (1) seafood (1) secrets (1) senses (1) sentient swords (1) session starters (1) setting questions (1) settings (1) shoes (1) shopping (1) side effects (1) side-effects (1) site features (1) sites (1) so tables (1) software (1) soirées (1) song tables (1) songs (1) sounds (1) speak with animals (1) speak with dead (1) speak with plants (1) spears (1) special attacks (1) special results (1) specials (1) spell casting (1) spell substitutes (1) springs (1) statues (1) statutes (1) stomachs (1) stories (1) streams (1) streets (1) strict time keeping (1) subsystems (1) surprise (1) swanson abilities (1) swansong abilities (1) table talk (1) task resolution (1) tattoos (1) taverns (1) taxes (1) tea (1) telepathy (1) terrain (1) the middle road (1) thief (1) thieves cant (1) tieflings (1) timekeeping (1) tinkering (1) tomes (1) toys (1) tpk (1) trade goods (1) traders (1) travel (1) treasure maps (1) trees (1) trinkets (1) turn undead (1) urban crawls (1) value (1) venoms (1) vermin (1) voronoi (1) wands (1) waterskins (1) weather (1) whence tables (1) wilderness stocking (1) wildlife (1) word games (1) xp (1) ynn (1) zero hp (1)

Blog Archive